Research for stronger health systems during and after crisis

Internal contracting of health services in Cambodia: drivers for change and lessons learned after a decade of external contracting

Vong, S., Raven, J. and Newlands, D. (2018) Internal contracting of health services in Cambodia: drivers for change and lessons learned after a decade of external contracting BMC Health Services Research 18:375 https://doi.org/10.1186/s12913-018-3165-z

 

This paper is an output of ReBUILD’s research into health contracting models in Cambodia. The study investigates how the Cambodian Ministry of Health implemented the ‘Special Operating Agencies’ (SOA) model of internal contracting since 2009, and identifies effects on service delivery, challenges in operation and lessons learned. The study concluded that capacity in planning and monitoring contracts at different levels in the health system is required, and that service delivery will be undermined if effective performance management is not established nor continuously applied. Recommendations for improvements in the implementation of SOA are given.

Access the full paper here, or read the abstract below.

 

Abstract

Background

Since the late 1990s, contracting has been employed in Cambodia in an attempt to accelerate rural health system recovery and improve health service delivery. Special Operating Agencies (SOA), a form of ‘internal contracting’, was introduced into selected districts by the Cambodia Ministry of Health in 2009. This study investigates how the SOA model was implemented and identifies effects on service delivery, challenges in operation and lessons learned.

Methods

The study was carried out in four districts, using mixed methods. Key informant interviews were conducted with representatives of donors and the Ministry of Health. In-depth interviews were carried out with managers of SOA and health facilities and health workers from referral hospitals and health centres. Data from the Annual Health Statistic Report 2009–2012 on utilisation of antenatal care, delivery and immunisation were analysed.

Results

There are several challenges with implementation: limited capacity and funding for monitoring the SOA, questionable reliability of the monitoring data, and some facilities face challenges in achieving the targets set in their contracts. There are some positive effects on staff behaviour which include improved punctuality, being on call for 24 h service, and perceived better quality of care, promoted through adherence to work regulations stipulated in the contracts and provision of incentives. However, flexibility in enforcing these regulations in SOA has led to more dual practice, compared to previous contracting schemes. There are reported increases in utilization of services by the general population and the poor although the quantitative findings question the extent to which these increases are attributable to the contracting model.

Conclusion

Capacity in planning and monitoring contracts at different levels in the health system is required. Service delivery will be undermined if effective performance management is not established nor continuously applied. Improvements in the implementation of SOA include: better monitoring by the central and provincial levels; developing incentive schemes that tackle the issues of dual practice; and securing trustworthy baseline data for performance indicators.